Kate and I started reading John Piper’s book “Contending for Our All: Defending Truth and Treasuring Christ in the Lives of Athanasius, John Owen, and J. Gresham Machen.” So far (part way through the introduction) Piper has been defending the idea that controversy and disagreement are not contrary to the healthy growth of the church. In fact, he wants to claim that certain kinds of controversy are beneficial to the church. Here are some quotes that we came across that I liked.
“It is perfectly true, of course, that argument alone is quite insufficient to make a man a Christian. You may argue with him from now until the end of the world; you may bring forth the most magnificent arguments—but all will be in vain unless there is one other thing: the mysterious, creative power of the Holy Spirit in the new birth. But because argument is insufficient, it does not follow that it is unnecessary. Sometimes it is used directly by the Holy Spirit to bring a man to Christ. But more frequently it is used indirectly.”
J. Gresham Machen
I appreciated the above quote because I need to be consistently reminded that argumentation is not sufficient to bring a person to Jesus. Even if I’ve thought of every possible recourse a person may have for avoiding Christ and can challenge those one after the other, the person will remain resistant to the beckoning invitation of Jesus until God works sovereignly to move the heart of the individual. At the same time, I offer my hearty support to Machen’s insistence that God does use argumentation as one possible instrument in the opening of a person to the beauty and truth of Jesus Christ.
“Historically, controversies that have swirled around the meaning and implications of the Gospel, far from damaging the Church, have contributed to its vitality. Like a refiner’s fire, intense theological debate has resulted in clarified belief, common vision, and invigorated ministry.”
Parker Williamson
“Awakening and reformation are caused and carried by more clear perception of the glories of Christ and the repugnance of sin; and when these are seen more clearly and spoken of more precisely, division is more likely than when Christ is spoken of in vague terms and people care little for his name.”
John Piper
This book is available on John Piper’s website for free in PDF format:
http://www.desiringgod.org/ResourceLibrary/OnlineBooks/ByTitle/2401_Contending_For_Our_All/
It can also be purchased at DesiringGod.org (cheaper than Amazon.com):
http://www.desiringgod.org/Store/Books/ByTopic/All/658_Contending_For_Our_All/